punchmyface: (just let me get my magnifying glass.)
Sherlock Holmes ([personal profile] punchmyface) wrote2012-03-01 11:58 pm
Entry tags:

PERMISSIONS LIKE A BOSS | for [community profile] scorched

So.




"Sherlock, you didn't even try."
(via tumblr)



Sherlock Fucking Holmes. I'm going to need some permissions up in this piece for this lunatic.

As you probably know, Sherlock is famous (or nefarious, depending on your opinion) for being ridiculously observant. However, this version is far from all-knowing. It would be quite a godmode if he was, and where'd be the fun in that?

However, keeping him observant but not god-modey if he comes across your character will take some work, especially if I'm not terribly familiar with your canon. (I try, but I'm not omnipotent either. :) I am sure this will lead me to asking you absurd questions at unexpected times, but I thought some pro-active permissions-y thingies might help out, if you are so inclined.

So, a bit of a rundown on his deductive method.

Things he can do:

Notice everything – tangible. Five senses stuff. What you’re wearing, how you sound, your jewelry, your scent, your gait, etc etc. If you're from a world similar to his he may have a pretty good frame of reference for pegging you correctly based on this kind of information. If not… well, excellent, he really needs to work on learning he can't always be right. ;)

Things he can't do:

He is not psychic. Everything he does is, essentially, guesswork. He relies upon the senses, so especially if you have a superpower that is suppressed until manifested, he can't just divine that you have it. In Anatole, that will put you at more of an advantage than he would like, but he's just going to have to get used to it.

If you'd like to help me out by giving some preliminary details Sherlock can or can't notice when meeting your character, I'd be grateful! Even so, I'll undoubtedly also have to rely on icons, context clues, and late night inquiries about what dirt might be stuck on your character's shoes. But that is the fun in roleplaying (or maybe I'm just a freak!), so I look forward to it.

Handy dandy text box is available below.

1. Is there anything you'd like (or not like) for Sherlock to read based on observation of your character? Remember he looks for concrete details, so unless a super power has an obvious physical manifestation, it will go blissfully undetected. :)




And a second, although somewhat related matter. Still, I don't think it would affect everyone, so I'm putting it here separately.

I'm well-aware that I am playing an incarnation of one of the most recognizable characters in Western literary canon. Although the policy on 4th-walling at Scorched is generally "don't," I also can't ignore how many subsequent works of fiction were not only influenced by the character of Sherlock Holmes but tend to directly reference him. I know the BBC version is quite different (i.e. the modern setting, etc), but I also don't want to force anyone's character to not even recognize the name "Sherlock Holmes" if, canonically, they would. (Kuroshitsuji and Detective Conan, I'm looking at you, and I'm sure there are others.)

Somewhat luckily, due to canon point reasons, Sherlock will be trying to pass unnoticed as himself for the time being, so he won't just be handing out his name to passersby. Still, I don't anticipate this lasting forever, so I'd love to have a chat in case you think your character would respond to someone sporting the iconic name. I'm sure we can figure out something that isn't too 4th-wall-breaking. I tend to welcome chaos and confusion, so come at me, bro. :D

2. Would your character canonically recognize the character of Sherlock Holmes and you'd feel uncomfortable obfuscating it? Any ideas on how said character might react if s/he was introduced to Sherlock by name?



That's it! Thanks so much for sticking with me through this super ranty permissions post! Happy playing, and I hope Sherlock will encounter your character soon. >8)
fearcutsdeeper: (prayer.)

[personal profile] fearcutsdeeper 2012-03-08 11:49 pm (UTC)(link)
1. Is there anything you'd like (or not like) for Sherlock to read based on observation of your character? Arya looks more or less like this, albeit probably in dress that's slightly more modern in line with Anatole's steampunky nature. They'll be boys' clothes, though, and he should be able to discern from their wear and tear that she spends a lot of time on her feet, moving around the city, and practicing swordplay (she's left-handed, and usually carries a sword, but both hands are pretty callused since before coming here she did menial work as a castle servant and then was living on the road). That being said, he'll be able to recognize her as a girl -- though she's passed convincingly as a boy for a long time, she starts being recognized more as a girl around the canon point I've pulled her from. He might note that her mannerisms are pretty boyish, though. In general, she's light on her feet, is generally alert to her surroundings, and doesn't really relax too much, nor draw attention to herself very much -- though she's gotten better since coming here, she was on the run for a long time, and is good at sort of going unnoticed. Obviously she's a child, but she might come off as slightly older than she is due to what she's experienced back in her home world (being a fugitive, war, having to kill people) and that edge of solemness is probably at least partially discernible by an astute person not from that environment.

2. Would your character canonically recognize the character of Sherlock Holmes and you'd feel uncomfortable obfuscating it? Any ideas on how said character might react if s/he was introduced to Sherlock by name? Nope! There's no Sherlock Holmes in Westeros. 8)
Edited 2012-03-08 23:51 (UTC)
fearcutsdeeper: (lol.)

[personal profile] fearcutsdeeper 2012-03-11 08:28 pm (UTC)(link)
OH MAN YES. I haven't seen BBC Sherlock but I know exactly what you're talking about from the original stories and YES I WOULD LOVE ARYA TO DO THIS. Let's make it happen :D